It is time for the Israeli government and Jewish defense organizations to begin
actively combating the dangerous phenomena of Holocaust distortion
Recent events in four different Eastern European countries have once again highlighted
the ongoing assault on the accepted Holocaust narrative in the post-communist
world. Three attracted considerable attention, while the fourth, which perhaps
affords us the best insight into the phenomenon of Eastern European attempts
to rewrite World War II history, was virtually ignored, until it aroused a
solitary Jewish protest.
In Kiev, Odessa and Lviv, on January 1, hundreds marched to mark the birthday
of Ukrainian nationalist hero Stepan Bandera, who headed the Organization of
Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN ), which collaborated with the Nazis and actively
participated in the mass murder of Jews following the German occupation of
Ukraine in 1941. A few days later, the regional council of the Ukrainian oblast
of Ivano-Frankivsk declared 2012 the year of the UPA, the military wing of
the OUN.
From Estonia, on December 27, it was reported that the country's defense
ministry planned to submit a bill to parliament that would recognize Estonians
who served in the 20th Waffen-SS Grenadier Division, which fought alongside
German troops as "freedom fighters" for the country's independence - despite the fact that Nazi Germany had no intention
of granting Estonia freedom. While the Waffen-SS division did not participate
in Holocaust crimes (by the time it was established the Jews of Estonia had
already been murdered ), its members included men who had previously been involved
in killing Jews and Gypsies.
In Zagreb and Split, Croatia, memorial masses were conducted on December
28 to honor Ante Pavelic, its World War II head of state, who bears responsibility
for the mass murder of hundreds-of-thousands of Serbs, 30,000 Jews and several
thousand Roma. Pavelic, who was installed by the Germans, created one of the
most lethal and brutal regimes in Axis-dominated Europe.
The fourth event involved former Lithuanian foreign minister Vygaudas
Usackas, currently the EU Special Representative to Afghanistan, who wrote
a Wall Street Journal op-ed in which he characterized the Nazi occupation of
his homeland during the years 1941-1945 as "a few years' respite from the communists."
In view of the fact that 96.4 percent of the 220,000 Lithuanian Jews who
lived there under the German occupation were murdered (along with thousands
more Jews deported there from Western and Central Europe ), many by local Nazi
collaborators, Usackas' description was grossly insensitive, if not outright
outrageous. Yet in response to my criticism, Usackas issued a public statement
in which he justified his original text by pointing to the unbalanced treatment
in Western public opinion of "the crimes of Stalin's regime ... and the tragedy of its victims," which had only recently received due legal recognition, "in contrast to Nazi crimes which have been universally condemned by all civilized
humanity." And while he did reiterate an earlier condemnation of Holocaust crimes in general,
his comments did not mention a word about the tragic plight of Lithuanian Jewry
or the horrific crimes committed by Lithuanians during the "respite" from Soviet occupation.
Such callous indifference to the fate of over 200,000 Lithuanian citizens,
murdered in many cases by their own countrymen, may seem shocking coming from
an official representative of the European Union, but recent events in Lithuania
clearly indicate the government's determination to rewrite the history books
to cover up the crimes of local Nazi collaborators. In this regard, one example
stands out: a conference held in the Seimas (Lithuanian parliament ) last June
to mark the 70th anniversary of the German invasion. The conference's main
purpose was to glorify the Lithuanian Activist Front, a political group that
collaborated with the Nazis in the hope of reestablishing Lithuanian independence,
and that openly called for violence against the Jews. This incitement was a
factor in the widespread attacks on Jews in 46 Lithuanian communities even
before the arrival of Nazi troops - a well-documented phenomenon whose existence
was denied at the conference.
All of the above cases can best be described as "Holocaust
distortion" (as opposed to denial ), which seeks to promote the canard of historical equivalency
between Nazi and communist crimes, thereby denying the Holocaust its rightful
place as a unique case of genocide. Such distortion also minimizes the highly
significant role of Hitler's Eastern European collaborators in Holocaust crimes
and paves the way for the rehabilitation of those who fought against the Soviets,
regardless of any crimes they may have committed against Jews. It is this ideological
foundation that spawned all four events described above.
This approach was originally formulated in the Prague Declaration of June
3, 2008, which can properly be categorized as the official "manifesto of Holocaust distortion." The declaration's original signatories - 27 leading Eastern European political
leaders and intellectuals - openly warn that Europe will never be united until
it "recognize[s] communism and Nazism as a common legacy," and makes practical demands that if accepted would lead to a revolutionary reevaluation
of World War II history, and turn the Holocaust into just another of many similar
tragedies. Unfortunately, resolutions supporting these principles have already
passed by a wide margin in the European Parliament and the Parliamentary Assembly
of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe.
It is time for the Israeli government and Jewish defense organizations
to begin actively combating these dangerous phenomena, lest the successes achieved
during recent decades in Holocaust commemoration and education worldwide be
erased by those trying to conceal the crimes of their countrymen. haaretz.com
|