The
foreign minister of Lithuania did not wait until the
day was over.
“It is not possible to find differences between Hitler and Stalin except in
their moustaches (Hitler’s was shorter).”
— The Foreign Minister of Lithuania, commenting upon the Seventy Years Declaration
in the early hours of 20 January 2012, 70th anniversary of the Wannsee Conference
The day was January 20th 2012. The seventieth anniversary of the Wannsee Conference
codifying the “Final Solution” — the annihilation of
European Jewry. Lithuania had Europe’s highest percentage
of Jewish citizens killed in all of wartime Europe, in
some measure due to the massive local collaboration and
participation in the killings of its Jewish population
(which incidentally, made the inspirational courage of
the rescuers all the more momentous). Given his government’s
recent investments in “Jewish public relations projects”
a solemn silence until the end of the day might have
been expected. Or even a statement about the Holocaust
which all but wiped out Lithuanian Jewry. After all the
Wannsee Conference came right after “those six months”
in which most of Lithuanian Jewry was massacred (with
a minority kept alive for slave labor in four ghettos).
Instead, according to a 20 January 2012 report on Lrytas.lt timestamped 8:26
PM (English translation here), foreign minister Audronius
Ažubalis, via his spokesperson Margarita Butkienė, condemned
the eight of his nation’s Social Democrats (six MPs plus
two MEPs) who signed the Seventy Years Declaration launched
by seventy European parliamentarians from nineteen European
Union member states. The Seventy Years Declaration, issued
to mark Friday’s anniversary of Wannsee, opposes “Double
Genocide” and condemns Soviet crimes while making it
clear they are not “equal” to the Nazis’ genocide. It
also opposes the glorification of local East European
Holocaust perpetrators and the legalization of public
swastikas.
In fact, it appeared that
the foreign minister did not even wait until the crack
of dawn of 20 January. His statement was earlier the
subject of a Lietuvos žinios (Lžinios.lt) report timestamped
3:53 AM (English translation here), less than four hours
after the Seventy Years Declaration was published by
DefendingHistory.com at midnight. The Lžinios.lt online
version cites quotations in reply by two of the Social
Democratic MPs who signed the declaration, Algirdas Sysas
and Justinas Karosas.
“If we’re discussing painful matters, gas chambers and deportation, these are
somewhat different things. People still used to come
back from deportation, but usually not from the gas chambers.”
— Comment of Social Democratic MP Algirdas Sysas, in
reply to the foreign minister’s attack on Lithuanian
parliamentarians who signed the Seventy Years Declaration.
“The conservatives pushed this position, but it’s not one universally accepted
in Lithuania. This is a kind of political gambit by the
conservatives, this is their kind of battle. But Social
Democrats have always seen it differently.”
— Comment of Social Democratic MP Justinas Karosas, in reply to the foreign minister’s
attack on Lithuanian parliamentarians who signed the Seventy Years Declaration.
An elderly Holocaust survivor told DefendingHistory.com today: “For the first
time in many years, I feel pride in some members of our
parliament who now have the courage to stand up to the
extreme nationalists who are trying in their own way
to write the Holocaust out of history with their ‘Two
Holocausts’ theory. These incredibly courageous parliamentarians
are the true Lithuanian patriots and they make me proud
to be a citizen.”
But the foreign minister called the decision to sign the Seventy Years Declaration
“pathetic”. The minister goes on to accuse the founding signatories of
the statement of “echoing the Kremlin’s ideologues: Stalin ‘good’ and
Hitler — bad”.
Most sensationally, Foreign Minister Ažubalis goes on to say:
“It is not possible to find differences between Hitler and Stalin except
in their moustaches (Hitler’s was shorter).”
His statement goes on to list as irrefutable truth the various
“red-brown resolutions” in the spirit of the (widely criticized) 2008
Prague Declaration, including the European Parliament’s (nonbinding)
2009 vote recommending a unitary day of commemoration of Nazi and Soviet
crimes, and the OSCE’s declaration of July 2009.
Ažubalis’s diatribe accuses the Social Democrats who signed of going in a direction
opposite to that of the trend in Europe using the red-brown movement’s
2008 and 2009 triumphs as evidence. But he did not mention that the momentum
was sensationally halted in December 2010 when the European Union nixed
the attempt to insert “Double Genocide” language in the Stockholm Declaration,
referring in its report to the Montero Report, and the simple fact that
there is no “one size fits all” for European resolutions on history.
The Guardian reported on 21 December 2010. [That end-of-the-year 2010
reversal was more recently the subject of the October 2011 outburst by
the right-wing MEP Vytautas Landsbergis at a European Parliament meeting.]
The Lithuanian right wing ruling party’s prominent (and in
some views, compliant) Jewish MP, Emanuelis Zingeris, now the head of
parliament’s foreign relations committee, has yet to comment publicly.
He was the only Jew in Europe to sign the 2008 Prague Declaration that
propelled the East European nationalist movement to “equalize” Nazi and
Soviet crimes (“Double Genocide”; see summary of opposition). He is also
the founding chairman of the highly controversial “red-brown commission”
(see summary of opposition). There is also speculation as to whether
his older brother, the eminent author Markas Zingeris, now head of the
state’s Jewish museum and the formal “Advisor on Genocide” to the prime
minister will be issuing a statement clarifying his own view. The Seventy
Years Declaration includes a line on the definition of genocide.
Foreign Minister Ažubalis has never apologized for an antisemitic
outburst of October 2010 at a meeting of his party faction in the Lithuanian
Seimas (parliament) that drew an anguished reaction from the Jewish Community
of Lithuania and has generated a substantial paper trail.
Earlier this month, Ažubalis’s predecessor as foreign minister,
Vygaudas Ušackas, now the European Union’s ambassador to Afghanistan,
was taken to task for having called Nazi rule “a respite from the communists”
in a December 2011 article in the Wall Street Journal.
In the meantime, DefendingHistory.com has issued a statement
congratulating the six Lithuanian members of parliament and two of its
members of the European Parliament who signed the Seventy Years Declaration
for their “extraordinary courage, integrity and true love of their country
and European values”. defendinghistory.com
|